Not real a fair comparison given the age differences, but interesting to compare old traditions of big barrels, Botti and 5kL Slovenian oak compared with more modern rotary fermenters and barriques, but interesting never the less.
Altare.
Altare's 2012 Barolo is soft, open-knit and succulent. Sweet floral notes meld into red-fleshed berries, tobacco, mint, licorice and spices. Silky tannins and a sense of freshness give the 2012 much of its early appeal. This is an especially gracious, mid-weight style for Altare. This soft, easygoing Barolo should drink well pretty much upon release. The Barolo is made from a collection of plots in La Morra, Castiglione Falletto, Serralunga and Barolo. This is the second vintage that includes Liste in the blend.
Elio Altare - Barolo DOCG Arborina
Ratti
Noble and generous, a glory of Old Piedmont, it is a wine suited to very long aging. Barolo is the absolute master of the dining room. It conquers the palate with strength, harmony and fullness and maintains its power at length. A great wine for important dishes, red meats roasted on a spit or grilled, game, dishes of gourmet white and red meats and ripe cheeses. Garnet red. Fragrance with notes of licorice and tobacco. Full and elegant flavor." - Winemaker Notes
Iris, rose, botanical herb and dark spice aromas lead the way in this fragrant red, along with an enticing whiff of graphite. Elegantly structured and boasting youthful tension, the vibrant palate delivers juicy Morello cherry, crushed raspberry, cinnamon and star anise framed in taut, refined tannins. It's balanced and focused, with bright acidity. Drink 2024-2036.
Barolo DOCG Marcenasco - Cantina Ratti