I'm assuming you didn't take advantage of the DSC offer given your dislike for it?
While endlessly telling us how Gold is the new Platinum, or the other way around, JohnK has booked enough DSC flights for 2 years of P1
just kidding.
I think discussions of benefits, lounge issues(potential and current) and so on are a whole different thread really
yes, this is a very generous promotion by QF, and reflects where they are at and with the recent Double Points promo seems to point to what their short-medium term goals/needs are.
As for arrivals access (domestic) for WP/WP1 - honestly I think most people don't use it. I may have used it twice in the last year - one of those due to an early arrival in BNE and I spent maybe 30min in the lounge before train in the city to hotel. Another time was at some place(I forget where, maybe ADL) where I wanted a pit stop and a quick drink before meeting a mate. Most people, myself included, just want to get where we're going (moreso if at home base) so I really don't think that will be a big issue. Moreso the lounges don't appear to record numbers that use arrivals (I've always just been waved through, no card scan for example) so how would they know apart from anecdotal evidence (and I know some people will point to this and say so it's easy to revoke on this basis alone)
the other point about dilution of the elite level crowds, benefits etc is that seems to me every other day someone has posted over the past few years of getting a DSC or +50% SC offer personally. Let's say over the last 18 months 50% of the QFF population may have got these things - and of those a certain number would take advantage - over the entire QFF population, I imagine only a similar number would have used this DSC promo.
My point is that I feel the expected influx of elite-lites is probably not much more than one is currently seeing due to targeted offers.
I'm a self funded flyer 100% I got my first year P1, in part, from a DSC offer then the past 2 years have self funded, and this year (headed into my 4th year) I have 90% self funded, and just added one flight from this promo to get me over the line. very nice, but I probably would have done it anyway - this just means I get there sooner. net change to QF = some extra revenue (but maybe a little less than they might have got, in reality).
there's clearly a reason the bean counters have done this. I suspect they think the week's booking window was short enough to not make a massive number of elites
one also has to remember those NB's and PS's that may have taken this up are, likely, rare flyers anyway so what's it matter if they become Gold or WP but still only fly a few trips a year? Most people's travel patterns are unlikely to change in a huge way as a result of being bumped up a level or two in status. Maybe business swiped from VA (which is good for QF) from some, but otherwise it's probably going to be a smallish ripple in the elite "pond"
my 2 cents.