well what a coincidence Tango. I returned a whitebox shiraz 2012 or whatever the recent one was to dannys, swapped it for my first ever Tassie pinot and had a smile all over. firstly because the pinot was damn good for $26 and secondly I got the full $16.20 refund. I found it totally underwhelming when you consider VM shirazes at under twelve. Tango, it could have been the year also as we all know. They certainly vary, but once again, individual tastes.
Beefarmer - coincidence indeed. I haven't had the 2012 but it could just be that my palate is different to yours. I recently had a 2012 St Huberts Pinot Noir between four of us, two of us loved the funkiness of it and the fact that it was a pinot with decent body, the other two hated it. This scored 95 from James Halliday.
Each to their own??
PS - just had the Tomich Hill Winemaker Reserve Pinot Noir - fairly nice drop that I think most people would enjoy but like other's said, probably not worth the $45 from the winery! It got better after about 1.5hrs open.
Edit - will probably put the rest away for a couple of years.
Last edited: